Peer Review Portfolio
John Comer

CONTENTS

  1. Background
  2. Course Goals
  3. Instructional Practices: Methods, Materials and Assignments
  4. Assessment
  5. Lessons From a Course Portfolio
  6. Appendices
    1. Appendix A: Course Syllabus
    2. Appendix B: Student Questionnaire
    3. Appendix C: Focus Group
    4. Appendix D: Bias in news
    5. Appendix E: Public Opinion
    6. Appendix F: Format of Paper
  7. Student Work
    1. Sample Paper
    2. Poll Paper
    3. Focus Group Paper
    4. Bias in Media Paper

    Syllabus

     

    FALL SEMESTER, 2000

    POLLS, POLITICS, AND PUBLIC OPINION

    POLITICAL SCIENCE/SPEECH COMMUNICATION 334

    INSTRUCTOR: JOHN COMER

    OFFICE: 509 OLDFATHER

    PHONE: 472-3222, HOURS: 12:30-1:30 MWF or by appointment

    E-Mail: jcomer1@unl.edu

    COURSE DESCRIPTION: Writers on democracy generally place a great deal of importance on the political participation of the individual citizen. However, few courses in political science pay much attention to the individual citizen. Polls, Politics, and Public Opinion is one that does. It treats the attitudes and behavior of citizens with respect to politics, how these attitudes and behaviors are shaped, and what influence they have on government. It is a survey course and covers a number of topics. Although it is an upper division course, and therefore the content is somewhat demanding, one need not have taken other courses in political science or speech communication.

    TEXTS:

    How The News Media Fail by Dautrich and Hartley

    Public Opinion by Glynn, Herbst, O’Keefe, and Shapiro

    Public Opinion: Measuring the American Mind by Bardes and Oldendick

    Voter’s Guide to Election Polls, Traugott and Lavrakas

    REQUIREMENTS:

    Midterm and final examination. These can be short answer, multiple choice, essay (takehome or inclass) or any combination. Unannounced quizzes are also a possibility.

    Research Paper. Five to ten page research paper based on presidential election poll. Tentative due state, November 10

    Other Assignments. Identified below.

    Grade: Examinations = 60%, Papers = 25%, Other assignments and activities = 15%.

    Weekly Assignments:

    Aug. 21

    Course Introduction. Activity: Distribute questionnaire to students. Collect and process for later use.

    Aug. 23

    Topic for discussion: What is public opinion? Public Opinion, pp. 14 -30, American Mind, pp. 4-7. Activity: Brainstorm small groups.

    Aug. 25

    Topic for discussion: What are the principle components of definitions in Public Opinion on pp. 17-24 and which definition do you prefer? Why? Activity: Brainstorm small group

    Aug. 28

    Topic of discussion: What are the properties or characteristics of public opinion? Activity: Graphically display each property. Graphically display various distributional shapes or patterns of public opinion and discuss their implications or importance. Public Opinion, pp. 26-28.

    Aug. 30

    Topic of discussion: Discerning public opinion before public opinion polls? How was it done? How are the measurement and expression of public opinion tied together? Public Opinion, pp. 48-62. How does polling impact public opinion?

    Sept. 1

    Topic of discussion: Measuring public opinion: The use of surveys: survey questions. Assignment : Develop a survey statement or question designed to measure opinions toward public school vouchers. Public Opinion, pp. 76-77; American Mind, pp. 52- 62; pp. 215-216; 218-220, Voters Guide, Chapter 7.

    Sept. 4

    Labor Day Holiday

    Sept. 6

    Activity: Critique survey questions on vouchers.

    Sept. 8

    No Class

    Sept. 11

    Topic of discussion: Measuring public opinion: The use of surveys: sampling. Activity: Drawing a random sample. Why random? American Mind, pp. 47-52; Voters Guide, Chapter 5

    Sept. 13

    Topic of discussion: What are election polls? Voters Guide, Chapter 2

    Sept. 15

    Topic of discussion: Analyzing polling data, Voters Guide, Chapter 8.

    Sept. 18

    Topic of discussion: Evaluating surveys and some recent technological developments in polling, Voters Guide, Chapter 9, American Mind, pp. 220-222.

    Sept. 20

    Topic of discussion: The manipulative use of polls, American Mind, pp. 29-30, 216-218..

    Sept. 22

    Topic of discussion: Measuring public opinion: The use of focus groups. Activity: Focus group exercise. Public Opinion, pp. 80-89.

    Sept. 25

    Topic of discussion: Using focus group information. Assignment: Develop a campaign strategy for either Mr. Gore or Mr. Bush from information generated from the focus group. (themes, ads, whatever) to attract swing or undecided voters voters.

    Sept. 27

    Topic of discussion: Moving from the whole to the parts: Beliefs, values, attitudes and opinions, Public Opinion, pp. 104 -107, 268-274; American Mind, pp. 11-12. Activities: Describe a personal political or non political opinion belief, a value that flows from it, an attitude that flows from it, and finally an opinion that flows from it. (Hint: Pick an opinion and work backward.)

    Example:

    Belief: All human beings are equally deserving of a good life.

    Value: If individuals can not provide a good life for themselves than the community should provide it for them.

    Attitude: Favor a redistribution of wealth to insure that all have a good life

    Opinion: Favor a progressive income tax where the more one makes the higher percentage he or she pays in income taxes

    Sept 29

    Topic of Discussion: Are Americans selfish? American Mind, Chapter 7

    Oct. 2

    Topic of Discussion: What social class do you belong to? Public Opinion, pp. 226-229.

    Oct. 4

    Topic of Discussion: Are Americans racist? American Mind, Chapter 8, Public Opinion, pp. 231-235.

    Oct. 6

    Topic of discussion: Can a Jew be elected vice president? Public Opinion, pp. 357- 370.

    Oct. 9

    Topic of discussion: Can a homosexual teach in the public schools?

    Oct. 11

    Topic of Discussion: Perception: How and why and with what effect? Assignment: Watch and evaluate presidential debates. Activity: Assessing the perception of events and the factors that impact on them. This date will change depending on the debate schedule.

    Oct. 13

    Activity: Review the poll questionnaire. Review and field questions on procedures for poll.

    Oct. 16

    Fall Semester Break. Assignment: Students will conduct five interviews in their home town or, if in a rural unincorporated area, the county in which they live. Interviews should be conducted on October 13, 14, 15, 16, or 17. Completed interview schedules will be turned in on October 18. Students will also do a statistical analysis based on the responses from the pooled results of each student’s interviews. Due November 10th.

    Oct. 18

    Activity: Debriefing on interviewing. How did it go?

    Oct. 20

    Topic of Discussion: Yellow dog democrats or why I am a Democrat? American Mind, pp. 102-108

    Oct. 23

    Topic of Discussion: I am very conservative. How do I know, because I am consistently conservative on all the issues. American Mind, pp. 97-102, Public Opinion, 259-268, 274-276

    Oct. 25

    Topic of Discussion: Learning about politics or mommy where do opinions come from? American Mind, Chapter 5.

    Oct. 27

    Activity: Exploring one’s political socialization. Recollections of early political learning. Assignment. Monitor TV evening news on ABC, 5:30 Channel 7 for the 23th through 27th. Evaluate the content and bias of the news. Due on the 30th.

    Oct. 30

    Topic of Discussion: Media and Public Opinion: Does it have an impact? Public Opinion, pp. 388-411, American Mind, pp 91-95.

    Nov. 1

    Topic of Discussion: Political campaigns. Did the presidential election campaign influence you? Public Opinion, Chapter 12.

    Nov. 3

    Topic of Discussion: Tuesday’s Election

    Nov. 6

    Topic of Discussion: Understanding voter choice in American elections or answering the question who do I vote for? Public Opinion, pp. 253-268; 284-288. Activity: Electoral College Poll - Tie break: Distribution of the presidential vote in Nebraska. Winner excused from the final.

    Nov. 8

    Topic of Discussion: Understanding turnout in American elections or answering the question do I vote?

    Nov. 10

    Topic of discussion: What does the election mean? Public Opinion, pp. 213-221

    Nov. 13

    Midterm Examination

    Nov 15

    Topic of discussion: Media and Elections. How the News Fails, Chapters 5,6 and 7

    Nov. 17

    Topic of discussion: Media and Elections. How the News Fails, Chapters 5,6 and 7

    Nov. 20

    Topic of discussion: Are we on the threshold of a major political reform? Public Opinion, pp. 370-376, , American Mind, pp. 109-116.

    Nov. 22

    Student Holiday

    Nov. 24

    Thanksgiving Holiday

    Nov. 27

    Topic of discussion: The public’s impact on policy. First things first. Should the public have an influence?

    Nov. 29

    Topic of discussion: Public opinion as constraint, Public Opinion, pp 300-302

    Dec. 4

    Topic of discussion: The public’s influence on policy: Fitting the pieces together, Public Opinion, pp. 302-336

    Dec. 6

    Topic of discussion: Conclusions: Public Opinion and Democracy

    Dec. 8

    Topic of discussion: Taking stock and review.

    Dec. 11

    Final Examination, 10-12